The Victims

While Randy Kraft is suspected to have killed 67 people, he was only tried for 16 for numerous reasons.

Victim Eric Church image
Facial reconstruction of an unidentified victim Wilmington
killer-scorecard image
Victim Paul Joseph Fuchs image

All known victims below

The Scorecard Killer

Tried Victims

These victims a court of his peers determined he was guilty of killing.

  • Edward Moore (20) December 24, 1972
  • Kevin Bailey (17) April 9, 1973
  • Ronnie Wiebe (20) July 28, 1973
  • Keith Crotwell (18) March 29, 1975
  • Mark Hall (22) January 1, 1976
  • Scott Hughes (18) April 16, 1978
  • Roland Young (23) June 11, 1978
  • Richard Keith (20) June 19, 1978
  • Keith Klingbeil (23) July 6, 1978
  • Michael Inderbieten (21) November 18, 1978
  • Donald Crisel (20) June 16, 1979
  • Robert Loggins (19) August 23, 1980
  • Eric Church (21) January 27, 1983
  • Rodger DeVaul (20) February 12, 1983
  • Geoffrey Nelson (18) February 12, 1983
  • Terry Lee Gambrel (25) May 14, 1983

All Potential Victims

It’s worth pointing out Randy Kraft has never been tried for any of these victims and has never confessed. These victims due to his own notes and other evidence it’s likely he committed the crimes, but due to never being tried he is only a suspect in the cases.

While some of the bodies were never recovered, notes were written down in Krafts book suggests there were other crimes and murders.

 All of his suspected victims were males between the ages of 13 and 35 and quite a few were in the Marine Corps.

 

Joey Fancher (sex assault victim – survived)

  1.  Wayne Dukette
  2.  Edward Moore
  3. Unidentified Male
  4. Kevin Bailey
  5. unidentified youth
  6. Ronnie Wiebe
  7. Vincent Cruz Mestas
  8. Malcolm Little
  9. James Reeves
  10.  Roger Dickerson
  11. John Leras
  12. Craig Jonaitis
  13. Keith Crotwell
  14. Scott Michael Hughe
  15. Roland Young
  16. Richard Keith
  17. Keith Klingbeil
  18. Richard Crosby
  19. Michael Inderbieten
  20. Donald Crisel
  21. unidentified male
  22. Gregory Wallace Jolley
  23. Jeffrey Sayre
  24. Mark Alan Mars
  25. Michael O’Fallon (Portland)
  26. unidentified male (Portland)
  27. Robert Loggins
  28. Michael Cluck (Portland)
  29. Christopher Allen Williams
  30. Raymond Davis
  31. Robert Avila
  32. Arne Mikeal Laine
  33. Brian Whitcher (Portland)
  34. Anthony Jose Silveira (Portland)
  35. Dennis Alt (Grand Rapids)
  36. Christopher Schoenborn (Grand Rapids)
  37. Lance Taggs
  38. Eric Church
  39. Geoffrey Nelson
  40. Rodger DeVaul
  41. Terry Lee Gambrel

Due to the fact he already received the death penalty and is currently on death row waiting to be excuted, he is unlikely to be tried for these victims.

Maybe he will confess before he dies or maybe he will take them to his death.

Subscribe to MurderTown Email​

Are you interested in Serial Killers, join our mailing lists for the latest releases, crime updates and much much more.

By submitting your email address, you are agreeing to receive marketing emails from RandyKraft.com.
We’ll never share your email address and you can unsubscribe at any time.